Create a free account: save works to My list and get notified about new additions.

Sign up for free
Skip to content
SAJuR Library and Case Law
Court rulingFree download

M., V. R. s/ recurso de casación (causa 606/22, rechazo de reparación integral), expte. 1424/2023 STJ-SP

M., V. R. s/ appeal in cassation (causa 606/22, refusal of full reparation), expte. 1424/2023 STJ-SP

Antártida e Islas del Atlántico Sur Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego · 2023

Read on screenDownload

Openly licensed work: you can read and download it here.

Summary

In a case of injuries and theft with a woman as victim, the public defence applied for full reparation of the harm, with the complainant’s agreement, and the prosecutor supported it after assessing the context of gender-based violence and a psychological expert report. The investigating judge rejected it, invoking the prohibition of mediation or conciliation hearings in Article 28 of Law 26.485, and the Sala Penal of the Cámara annulled the prosecutor’s opinion and declared the cassation appeal inadmissible. On a direct appeal (queja), the Superior Tribunal admitted the appeal, set aside the ruling, declared the criminal action extinguished (Article 59(6) of the Código Penal) and dismissed the case (sobreseimiento). Its opinions hold that each case requires an assessment of whether the woman is deciding freely.

Topics

Used on the campus

Details

Authors
Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego, Antártida e Islas del Atlántico Sur
Year
2023
Publisher or source
Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego, expte. 1424/2023 STJ-SP (12/12/2023); copia publicada en el sitio del Poder Judicial
Type
Court ruling
Language
Spanish
Jurisdiction
Tierra del Fuego (Argentina), Superior Tribunal de Justicia
Court
Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego, Antártida e Islas del Atlántico Sur
Province or state
Tierra del Fuego
Date of ruling
12 de diciembre de 2023
Case no.
"M., V. R. s/ Recurso de casación (causa n° 606/22 `M., V. R. s/ Recurso de apelación rechazo de reparación integral s/ Recurso de Queja')", expte. n° 1424/2023 STJ-SP
What it decided
Granted
Provisions applied
Código Penal, art. 59 inc. 6
Ley 26.485, art. 28
Convención de Belém do Pará, art. 7
Código Procesal Penal de Tierra del Fuego, art. 309 inc. 1
Licence
Dominio público

Cite this work

Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego, A. I. A. S. (2023). M., V. R. s/ recurso de casación (causa 606/22, rechazo de reparación integral), expte. 1424/2023 STJ-SP. Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego, expte. 1424/2023 STJ-SP (12/12/2023); copia publicada en el sitio del Poder Judicial.

Follow SAJuR

News, training and events on social media.

Create your free account

Continue with Google

Sign up with my email