OGH 12 Os 84/12p: recurso de la fiscalía contra la forma de diversión elegida y conciliación (Tatausgleich) en el derecho penal juvenil
OGH 12 Os 84/12p: prosecution appeal against the form of diversion chosen and Tatausgleich (victim-offender mediation) in juvenile criminal law
Oberster Gerichtshof · 2012
Openly licensed work: you can read and download it here.
Summary
A court in Wels closed, after a Tatausgleich (victim-offender mediation), a case against a young woman for commercial theft. The prosecution appealed, arguing that there was no conflict between persons to mediate and that another form of diversion was appropriate, and the higher court dismissed the appeal for lack of standing. At the request of the Procurator General's Office, the Austrian Supreme Court (OGH) held that this dismissal violated the law: the prosecution may appeal the form of diversion chosen, because the one sufficient for preventive purposes must be selected and it cannot be combined with others. It also recalls that in juvenile criminal law mediation does not require the victim's consent (§ 8 para. 3 JGG). Useful for studying judicial review of juvenile criminal mediation.
Topics
Used on the campus
Details
- Authors
- Oberster Gerichtshof
- Year
- 2012
- Publisher or source
- Oberster Gerichtshof (Senado 12), 12 Os 84/12p, 10/10/2012, ECLI:AT:OGH0002:2012:0120OS00084.12P.1010.000
- Type
- Court ruling
- Language
- German
- Jurisdiction
- Austria
- Court
- Corte Suprema de Austria
- Date of ruling
- 10 de octubre de 2012
- Case no.
- 12 Os 84/12p
- What it decided
- Granted
- Provisions applied
- StPO (Austria), art. 198
StPO (Austria), art. 204
JGG (Austria), art. 8 - Licence
- CC BY