R v PBD [2019] QCA 59: derivación a un proceso restaurativo antes de la sentencia de una persona menor de edad (s 162(2) Youth Justice Act 1992)
Court of Appeal Supreme Court of Queensland · 2019
Openly licensed work: you can read and download it here.
Summary
A young person sentenced to twelve months' detention for grievous bodily harm appealed because the judge did not consider referring the case to a restorative justice process before passing sentence, as section 162(2) of Queensland's Youth Justice Act 1992 requires. The Court of Appeal distinguished the two pathways in the section: the restorative process instead of a sentence, and a prior referral to inform the sentence. It held that considering such a referral is mandatory and that the omission was an error of law, but dismissed the appeal: there was no indication that a conference would serve any purpose, because the young person showed no remorse and nothing suggested that the victim wished to take part, and without the victim there can be no conference. Useful for studying pre-sentence restorative processes in youth justice.
Topics
Used on the campus
Details
- Authors
- Supreme Court of Queensland, Court of Appeal
- Year
- 2019
- Publisher or source
- Supreme Court of Queensland, Court of Appeal (Sofronoff P, McMurdo JA y Wilson J), CA No 30 of 2019, 12/04/2019, [2019] QCA 59
- Type
- Court ruling
- Language
- English
- Jurisdiction
- Queensland (Australia)
- Court
- Corte de Apelaciones de Queensland (Supreme Court of Queensland)
- Province or state
- Queensland
- Date of ruling
- 12 de abril de 2019
- Case no.
- R v PBD [2019] QCA 59 (CA No 30 of 2019)
- What it decided
- Denied
- Provisions applied
- Youth Justice Act 1992 (Qld), art. 162
- Licence
- Dominio público