Tribunal de Impugnación de Río Negro, Sentencia N.º 90/2024 (MPF-BA-06400-2021): suspensión del juicio a prueba y razonabilidad de la oferta de reparación en una defraudación con querella
Tribunal de Impugnación de Río Negro, Judgment No. 90/2024 (MPF-BA-06400-2021): suspension of trial on probation and the reasonableness of the reparation offer in a fraud case with a private prosecutor
Tribunal de Impugnación de la Provincia de Río Negro · 2024
Openly licensed work: you can read and download it here.
Summary
The private prosecutor challenged the suspension of the trial on probation granted to a person charged with fourteen counts of fraud in the sale of plots of land, with a reparation offer of fifty million pesos in five instalments and 145 hours of community service, which the prosecution had accepted. The Tribunal de Impugnación upheld the challenge, revoked the suspension and ordered the proceedings to continue. Two of its members held that the reparation offer is a requirement of probation and that the judge must review its reasonableness in light of the harm and the means of the person making it. The third agreed with the outcome on other grounds and criticised a purely formal review. It is useful for prosecutors, defence counsel and private prosecutors.
Topics
Used on the campus
Details
- Authors
- Tribunal de Impugnación de la Provincia de Río Negro
- Year
- 2024
- Publisher or source
- Tribunal de Impugnación de Río Negro, Sentencia N.º 90, 16/05/2024, legajo MPF-BA-06400-2021
- Type
- Court ruling
- Language
- Spanish
- Jurisdiction
- Río Negro (Argentina)
- Court
- Tribunal de Impugnación de Río Negro
- Province or state
- Río Negro
- Date of ruling
- 16 de mayo de 2024
- Case no.
- Sentencia N.º 90 (MPF-BA-06400-2021)
- What it decided
- Granted
- Provisions applied
- Código Penal de la Nación, art. 76 bis
Código Procesal Penal de Río Negro (Ley 5020), art. 98 - Licence
- Dominio público