A., C. E. s/ amenazas con armas y daño reiterado (flagrancia), expte. 383/2017 STJ-SP y acumulado 396/2017
Antártida e Islas del Atlántico Sur Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego · 2017
Openly licensed work: you can read and download it here.
Summary
The judge of the correctional court refused to refer to the Mediation Centre a case of threats with a weapon and damage, requested by the defence with the consent of the prosecution and the victim, because the accused had a prior conviction and any sentence would have to be served in effect. The Superior Court admitted the complaints and the appeals in cassation, but by majority rejected them. Judge Battaini, dissenting, held that, under the «González» precedent, only the penalty range of the case counts and that the relationship between the parties made mediation advisable. The majority held that referral requires that the applicable sentence be capable of suspension, which was not the case because of the prior conviction.
Topics
Used on the campus
Details
- Authors
- Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego, Antártida e Islas del Atlántico Sur
- Year
- 2017
- Publisher or source
- Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego, expte. 383/2017 STJ-SP y acumulado 396/2017 (15/11/2017); jueces Battaini, Sagastume y Muchnik; copia publicada por Pensamiento Penal
- Type
- Court ruling
- Language
- Spanish
- Jurisdiction
- Tierra del Fuego (Argentina), Superior Tribunal de Justicia
- Court
- Superior Tribunal de Justicia de Tierra del Fuego
- Province or state
- Tierra del Fuego
- Date of ruling
- 15 de noviembre de 2017
- Case no.
- expte. 383/2017 STJ-SP y acumulado 396/2017
- What it decided
- Denied
- Licence
- Dominio público