Baigorri, Gastón Emiliano - Sotomayor, Ciro Agustín (robo) s/ recurso de casación (Sentencia n.º 10/2026)
Baigorri, Gastón Emiliano - Sotomayor, Ciro Agustín (robbery) s/ appeal in cassation (Sentencia n.º 10/2026)
Sala Penal Corte de Justicia de Catamarca · 2026
Openly licensed work: you can read and download it here.
Summary
Two defendants charged with simple robbery signed an agreement with the victim, providing for the return of what was taken and compensation of two million pesos. The Ministerio Público Fiscal rejected it on the basis of instructions issued by the Procuración, and the Juzgado de Control de Garantías denied dismissal on the ground of full reparation (Article 59(6) of the Código Penal) and ordered pre-trial detention; the Cámara de Apelaciones upheld that ruling. The defence appealed in cassation, arguing that exceptions not provided for by law were being added. By majority, the Sala Penal of the Corte dismissed the appeal: extinction depends on a reasoned and reasonable prosecutorial opinion, which here passed the legality review. A minority opinion proposed annulment for lack of reasoning.
Topics
Used on the campus
Details
- Authors
- Corte de Justicia de Catamarca, Sala Penal
- Year
- 2026
- Publisher or source
- Corte de Justicia de Catamarca, Sala Penal, Sentencia n.º 10 (16/03/2026), expte. Corte n.º 098/25; copia del buscador de jurisprudencia del Poder Judicial
- Type
- Court ruling
- Language
- Spanish
- Jurisdiction
- Catamarca (Argentina), Corte de Justicia
- Court
- Corte de Justicia de Catamarca, Sala Penal
- Province or state
- Catamarca
- Date of ruling
- 16 de marzo de 2026
- Case no.
- "Baigorri, Gastón Emiliano - Sotomayor, Ciro Agustín -robo- s/ rec. de casación c/ AI n° 64/25 de expte. nº 38/25" (expte. Corte nº 098/25)
- What it decided
- Denied
- Provisions applied
- Código Penal, art. 59 inc. 6
Ley 27.372 - Licence
- Dominio público