F. C. P. c/ Q. F. M. (legajo MPF-BA-00572-2017): suspensión del juicio a prueba y derecho de la mujer víctima a ser oída
F. C. P. c/ Q. F. M. (legajo MPF-BA-00572-2017): suspension of the trial on probation and the right of the woman victim to be heard
Tribunal de Impugnación de la Provincia de Río Negro · 2019
Openly licensed work: you can read and download it here.
Summary
A man was accused of three incidents of minor injuries and threats against his partner between December 2016 and March 2017. The public defence applied for suspension of the trial on probation (Article 98 of the Río Negro Code of Criminal Procedure) and argued that the woman was not proposing mediation or to have him released from the case, but a follow-up arrangement. The control-of-indictment judge denied it on 10/12/2018 and the review judge upheld that decision on 20/02/2019, without hearing the victim. The Tribunal de Impugnación annulled both rulings and the prosecutors’ opinions and remitted the case, because the decision had been taken without a gender perspective by not hearing the woman; it cites criticism of the automatic application of “Góngora”. Each side to bear its own costs.
Topics
Used on the campus
Details
- Authors
- Tribunal de Impugnación de la Provincia de Río Negro
- Year
- 2019
- Publisher or source
- Tribunal de Impugnación de Río Negro, Viedma (15/04/2019), legajo MPF-BA-00572-2017; copia publicada por Pensamiento Penal
- Type
- Court ruling
- Language
- Spanish
- Jurisdiction
- Río Negro (Argentina), Tribunal de Impugnación
- Court
- Tribunal de Impugnación de la Provincia de Río Negro
- Province or state
- Río Negro
- Date of ruling
- 15 de abril de 2019
- Case no.
- "F. C. P. C/Q F. M.", Legajo MPF-BA-00572-2017
- What it decided
- Granted
- Provisions applied
- Código Procesal Penal de Río Negro, art. 98
Código Procesal Penal de Río Negro, art. 266
Convención de Belém do Pará - Licence
- Dominio público