F., J. A. y otro s/ hurto (CCC 45815/2019/TO1/CNC1)
Sala I Cámara Nacional de Casación en lo Criminal y Correccional · 2020
Openly licensed work: you can read and download it here.
Summary
Two persons with prior convictions, charged with theft, reached conciliation with the injured party. Oral Trial Court No. 24, despite the opposition of the prosecution, which cited those prior convictions and criminal policy reasons, granted the conciliation, declared the criminal action extinguished and dismissed the case (sobreseimiento) against them; the prosecution appealed in cassation. Chamber I, by majority, allowed the appeal, set aside the ruling and remitted the file for the proceedings to continue (art. 59 para. 6 CP, arts. 25 and 34 CPPF). Judges Bruzzone and Rimondi held that, without a favourable prosecutorial opinion, the institution does not apply when the opinion is sufficiently reasoned and passes a review of legality and reasonableness.
Topics
Used on the campus
Details
- Authors
- Cámara Nacional de Casación en lo Criminal y Correccional, Sala I
- Year
- 2020
- Publisher or source
- Cámara Nacional de Casación en lo Criminal y Correccional, Sala I, CCC 45815/2019/TO1/CNC1, Reg. 2672/2020 (03/09/2020); copia publicada por Pensamiento Penal
- Type
- Court ruling
- Language
- Spanish
- Jurisdiction
- Ciudad de Buenos Aires (Argentina), justicia nacional (casación)
- Court
- Cámara Nacional de Casación en lo Criminal y Correccional, Sala I
- Province or state
- Ciudad de Buenos Aires
- Date of ruling
- 3 de septiembre de 2020
- Case no.
- CCC 45815/2019/TO1/CNC1
- Provisions applied
- Código Penal, art. 59 inc. 6
Ley 27.063 (CPPF), art. 25 y 34 - Licence
- Dominio público