Bordoni, Jorge Luis y otros p.ss.aa. propagación culposa de enfermedad peligrosa y contagiosa agravada (Sentencia n.º 331)
Bordoni, Jorge Luis y otros p.ss.aa. negligent spread of aggravated dangerous and contagious disease (Sentencia n.º 331)
Sala Penal Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Córdoba · 2011
Openly licensed work: you can read and download it here.
Summary
Three defendants charged with the negligent spread of an aggravated dangerous and contagious disease requested suspension of the trial on probation and offered sums of money as reparation. The Juzgado Correccional de Segunda Nominación de Córdoba denied it in three rulings, considering the offers unreasonable given the extent of the harm. The defence teams appealed in cassation; one argued that the reasonableness analysis had simply referred to the arguments of the private complainant. The Sala Penal of the Tribunal Superior held that such an assessment belongs, in principle, to the trial court and is reviewable only for arbitrariness, found none and dismissed the appeals, with costs. Because of that outcome, it did not address the grievances concerning the prosecutor’s consent (Article 76 bis, fourth paragraph).
Topics
Used on the campus
Details
- Authors
- Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Córdoba, Sala Penal
- Year
- 2011
- Publisher or source
- Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Córdoba, Sala Penal, Sentencia n.º 331 (07/11/2011), expte. «B» 4/2011; copia publicada por Pensamiento Penal
- Type
- Court ruling
- Language
- Spanish
- Jurisdiction
- Córdoba (Argentina), Tribunal Superior de Justicia
- Provisions applied
- Código Penal, art. 76 bis, 3.er párrafo
- Licence
- Dominio público