Court rulingTribunal Oral de Menores n.º 2 de la Capital Federal, causa CCC 44.290/2021/TO1: concilia…2023
Court rulingLink to source
Tribunal Oral de Menores n.º 2 de la Capital Federal, causa CCC 44.290/2021/TO1: conciliación en un delito con grave violencia cometido por un adolescente (art. 34 del Código Procesal Penal Federal)
Tribunal Oral de Menores n.º 2 de la Capital Federal, case CCC 44.290/2021/TO1: conciliation in an offence involving serious violence committed by an adolescent (art. 34 of the Código Procesal Penal Federal)
Tribunal Oral de Menores n.º 2 de la Capital Federal · 2023
The work is at its original source. Here you have the reference, a summary and the link.
Summary
A 2023 judgment that approved a conciliation agreement, drawn up in the Programa de Resolución Alternativa de Conflictos of the Defensoría General de la Nación, in a case of serious injuries inflicted with a firearm by an adolescent on their parent. The prosecution objected, but the court held that the rule does not require its consent and that the limitation in art. 34 of the Código Procesal Penal Federal (conciliation only for property offences without serious violence) does not apply in youth justice, relying on art. 40(3)(b) of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, the Beijing Rules and General Comment No. 24 of the Committee on the Rights of the Child. It declared the criminal action extinguished and dismissed the case against the adolescent. It is a precedent on the specialised nature of youth justice and on extrajudicial responses to serious offences.
Tribunal Oral de Menores n.º 2 de la Capital Federal
Year
2023
Publisher or source
Tribunal Oral de Menores n.º 2 de la Capital Federal, causa CCC 44.290/2021/TO1; veredicto del 02/06/2023 y fundamentos del 08/06/2023; copia publicada por la Asociación Pensamiento Penal
Type
Court ruling
Language
Spanish
Jurisdiction
Argentina (justicia nacional de menores, CABA)
Court
Tribunal Oral de Menores n.º 2 de la Capital Federal