Create a free account: save works to My list and get notified about new additions.

Sign up for free
Skip to content
SAJuR Library and Case Law
Court rulingLink to sourceGerman

Bundesgerichtshof, 5 StR 19/14: una carta de disculpa que minimiza el hecho («salió mal») pone en duda la asunción de responsabilidad del § 46a StGB

Bundesgerichtshof, 5 StR 19/14: an apology letter that plays down the offence (“it went wrong”) casts doubt on the acceptance of responsibility under § 46a StGB

5. Strafsenat Bundesgerichtshof · 2014

Go to the source ↗

The work is at its original source. Here you have the reference, a summary and the link.

Summary

After a planned assault involving strangulation and the use of a knife, the defendant wrote the victim an apology letter saying that things had “gone wrong” and that it was only by chance that she had been the one affected; the victim did not accept the apology. The Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) dismissed the appeal: playing down some details does not always rule out the Täter-Opfer-Ausgleich (victim-offender mediation), but such expressions cast doubt on the acceptance of responsibility required by § 46a No. 1. The efforts at redress, including the payment for non-material harm, had already been weighed in his favour in the sentence.

Topics

Used on the campus

Details

Authors
Bundesgerichtshof, 5. Strafsenat
Year
2014
Publisher or source
Bundesgerichtshof, 5. Strafsenat, Beschluss vom 11.03.2014, 5 StR 19/14 (LG Lübeck)
Type
Court ruling
Language
German
Jurisdiction
Alemania
Court
Tribunal Supremo Federal de Alemania (Bundesgerichtshof), Quinta Sala Penal
Date of ruling
11 de marzo de 2014
Case no.
5 StR 19/14
What it decided
Denied
Provisions applied
Código Penal alemán (StGB), art. 46a n.º 1
Código Penal alemán (StGB), art. 49 ap. 1
Licence
Dominio público

Cite this work

Bundesgerichtshof, 5. S. (2014). Bundesgerichtshof, 5 StR 19/14: una carta de disculpa que minimiza el hecho («salió mal») pone en duda la asunción de responsabilidad del § 46a StGB. Bundesgerichtshof, 5. Strafsenat, Beschluss vom 11.03.2014, 5 StR 19/14 (LG Lübeck). https://www.rechtsprechung-im-internet.de/jportal/?quelle=jlink&docid=JURE140005766&psml=bsjrsprod.psml&max=true

Follow SAJuR

News, training and events on social media.

Create your free account

Continue with Google

Sign up with my email